The Card Grading Guide

PSA, CGC, SGC, HGA — compared honestly

Updated June 2026

Grade Scale Reference

Grade	PSA	BGS	SGC	What it means
10	PSA 10 Gem Mint	BGS 10 Pristine	SGC 10	Perfect or near-perfect. No visible flaws.
9.5	—	BGS 9.5 Gem Mint	—	Near perfect. Minimal flaws under magnification.
9	PSA 9 Mint	BGS 9 Mint	SGC 9	Sharp corners, clean surface, minor imperfections.
8.5	—	BGS 8.5 NM-MT+	SGC 8.5
8	PSA 8 NM-MT	BGS 8 NM-MT	SGC 8	Slight surface wear, edges may show minor wear.
7	PSA 7 NM	BGS 7 NM	SGC 7	Light play wear visible. Still a presentable card.
6	PSA 6 EX-MT	—	SGC 6	Moderate wear, soft corners possible.
5	PSA 5 EX	—	SGC 5	Obvious wear, possible crease.
1-4	Heavily played	—	—	Significant damage, for completionists only.

WaxPulse tip: Most collectors target PSA 9+ for investment-grade cards. For cards under $50, raw is usually the better play — grading costs often exceed the value gain.

Grading Companies Compared

PSA

⚠️ High demand, slow turnaround

Economy: ~$25-50 · 3-6 months

Value tier: $100+ · 4-8 weeks

Best for: High-value cards, established names

Turnaround: Slowest of the major graders

Submit to PSA →

CGC

Certified Guaranty Company

✅ Fast growing, strong reputation

Economy: ~$22 · 4-8 weeks

Best for: Modern cards, TCG, budget grading

Same company as the comic-grading giant — reputation carries over.

Submit to CGC →

SGC

Sportscard Guaranty

✅ Speed play, flat pricing

Economy: $25 flat · 4-6 weeks

Best for: Vintage, speed, budget modern

SGC’s black tuxedo slabs are a collector-favorite aesthetic.

Submit to SGC →

HGA

Hybrid Grading Approach

🆕 Unique color-matched slabs

Economy: ~$30 · 4-8 weeks

Best for: Collectors who care about presentation

Color-matched slab to the card’s team colors.

Submit to HGA →

CSG

Certified Sports Guaranty

🆕 Fanatics-backed, growing

Economy: ~$20 · 4-8 weeks

Best for: Budget grading, new collectors

Submit to CSG →

Arena Club

🆕 Digital-first grading

Economy: No physical return option available

Best for: Investors who don’t need the physical card

Cards stay in a vault — you trade them digitally.

Learn more →

Which Grader Should You Use?

1 · Card value (raw estimate)?

2 · Timeline?

3 · Priority?

Not sure what to grade?

Ask WaxBot →